Choi (1997) | 1 | FHZ | Gwakhyangjunggi-san(藿香正氣散)Galgeunhaegi-tang(葛根解肌湯) | + | He-Ne laser | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Complety Improved |
Nam (2004) | 2 | FHZ | none | 1) -2) + | AC, IR, EHM(牛蒡子煎湯液) | PRS, VAS, Skin lesion area(%) | 1) PRS:80→5VAS:100→10AREA:100→02) PRS:77→10VAS100→10AREA:100→0 |
Bae (2000) | 1 | HZO | Yanggyeok-san(加減涼膈散)Seganmyungmok-tang(洗肝明目湯) | + | AC, Eye irrigation, Dressing, Carbon, HP, MWDs | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Skin lesion: Eruption cleared Pain(Eyelid)&Headache:+++→+ |
Koo (2003) | 1 | HZO | Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯)>Takrisodok-eum(托裏消毒飮)Insamyangyoung-tang(人蔘養榮湯) | NR | NR | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Skin lesion: Eruption cleared Headache:++~+++→- |
Min (2012) | 1 | HZO | Cheongheolhaedok-tang(淸熱解毒湯加減)Boa-tang(補兒湯) | + | AC, Cupping(wet), PA(山蔘, 黃連解毒湯) | Visual evaluation(Photography), Narrative description of Skin Lesions, VAS for Pain | Skin lesion: Vesicles cleared, Rash improvedVAS:10→1 |
Park (2018) | 1 | HZO | Siryeng-tang(柴苓湯)Bangpungtongseoung-San(防風通聖散加味) | + | AC | Visual evaluation(Photography), Narrative description of Skin Lesions, NRS | Skin lesion: Vesicles cleared, Rash improvedNRS6~8→2 |
Shin (2002) | 1 | HZG | Bangpungtongseoung-San(防風通聖散) | + | Simple dressing | Narrative description of skin lesions, Subject symptom evaluation | Skin lesion: Eruption cleared, Pigmentation+ Pain:++→- |
Chun (2004) | 1 | HZG | Hyungbangsabak-san(荊防瀉白散加味) | - | AC, BL, PA(黃連解毒湯, BV) | Narrative description of skin lesions&SymptomVAS(pain) | Skin lesion: Eruption clearedVAS:10→1 |
Huh (2007) | 2 | HZG | 1) Oryeong-san(五苓散)2) Jihwangbakho-tang(地黃白虎湯加減) | - | AC, PA(黃連解毒湯) | 1) Visual evaluation(Photography)2) Visual evaluation(Photography), VAS(pain) | 1) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared2) Skin lesion: Vesicles cleared, Rash improvedVAS10→3 |
Han (2008) | 2 | HZG | 1) Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯加味)Jihwangbakho-tang(地黃白虎湯加減)2) Jihwangbakho-tang(地黃白虎湯加味),Yanggyeoksanhwa-tang(涼膈散火湯) | + | 1) AC, PA(黃連解毒湯)2) AC, PA(黃連解毒湯), Simple dresisng | 1) Visual evaluation(Photography), VAS(pain)2) Visual evaluation(Photography), Narrative description of symptoms | 1) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS10→02) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared |
Jung (2008) | 3 | 1) HZG2) HZO3) HZG | Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯) | 1) +2) +3) - | 1) AC, BL, Cupping(wet), EHM(止痒靜)2) AC, BL, Cupping(wet), EHM(一效散)3) AC, BL, PA(黃連解毒湯) | Narrative description of Skin Lesions and Symptoms, VAS | 1) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS10→22) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS10→13) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS10→0 |
Noh (2011) | 1 | HZG | none | + | AC, EA | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Immediate Pain relief effect |
Kwon (2012) | 1 | HZG | Yangdokbackho-tang(陽毒白虎湯) | + | AC | Visual evaluation(Photography) VAS(pain) | Skin lesion: Eruption improved, Pigmentation+ VAS: 7→2 |
Kim (2012) | 1 | HZG | Yeoldahanso-tang(熱多寒少湯加味) | - | AC | Visual evaluation(Photography) VAS(pain)Subject symptom evaluation | Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS:10→0-1Numbness/hypersensitivity: +++→±, Fatigue:+++→± Insomnea:+++→± |
Lee (2015) | 1 | HZG | Bosaeng-tang(保生湯加減) | - | AC, IR | Narrative description of skin lesions VAS(pain) | Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS:8→0 |
Oh (2015) | 1 | HZG | Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯)SoeuminBojoongikgi-tang(少陰人補中益氣湯) | + | AC, PA(SBV) | Narrative description of skin lesions, VAS(pain),Questionnaire(SF-MPQ)Numbers of Wake up | Skin lesion: Eruption clearedVAS:4→0, SF-MPQ:18→0Number of wake up:6→0 |
Bae (2016) | 2 | HZG | Pyeongwi-san(平胃散)Yunryongkobon-dan(延齡固本丹) | - | AC, Su-Gi therapy, Extra Gigong Therapy | Visual evaluation(Photography), Narrative description of Skin Lesions, VAS for Pain | 1) Skin lesion: Eruption cleared VAS 9→02) Skin lesion: Vesicles cleared, Rash improved VAS8→0 |
Gong (2016) | 1 | HZG | Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯) | + | AC, Moxa, PA(CS, V) | VRSNPS | VRS 10→2, NPS(Sharpness 10→0, Burning 8→0, Dull pain 7→2, Coldness 3→0, Sensitivity 8→1, Itching 8→0, Discomfort 10→1, Deep pain 8→2, Superficial pain 10→1) |
Kim (1999) | 1 | RHS | Ligigeopoong-san(加味理氣祛風散) | + | AC, MWDs | Narrative description of Pain & Symptom | Pain & Facial pasly improved |
Park (2001) | 2 | RHS | Dokhwaljihwang-tang(獨活地黃湯) | NR | AC, Wet Cupping, Carbon, HP, Eye irrigation | HBG, Narrative description of Pain | 1) HBG: IV→III, Pain:+++→±2) HBG: IV→IV, Pain:+++→++ |
Kwon (2001) | 2 | RHS | 1) Yeoldahanso-tang(熱多寒少湯加味) Taeumin Chengsimyeonja-tang (太陰人淸心蓮子湯)2) Taeumin Galgeunhaegi-tang (太陰人葛根解肌湯) Yeoldahanso-tang(熱多寒少湯) | NR | AC, PA(CF, JSD) | HBG, YGS | 1) HBG: V→II, YGS: 4→392) HBG V→II, YGS: 4→39 |
Kim (2001) | 1 | RHS | Ligigeopoong-san(理氣祛風散加味)Bojoongikgi-tang(補中益氣湯加味) | + | AC, EA, IR | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Total symptoms slightly improved |
Cho (2001) | 1 | RHS | TaeuminChengsimyeonja-tang (太陰人淸心蓮子湯加味) | + | AC, Facial muscle exercise | FEMA grading system, HBG | FEMA scale: IV→0HBG: V→I |
Choi (2001) | 1 | RHS | Hyunggaeyenkyo-tang (荊芥連翹湯加味) | NR | AC, EA, Cupping(dry, wet), Moxa | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom | Total symptoms slightly improved |
Rhim (2003) | 1 | RHS | Goomiganghwaltang(九味羌活湯)Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯) | NR | AC, EHM(大黃梔子黃栢餠) | NRS for Pain & Vertigo, Narrative description of Symptom | NRS(Pain): 10→0NRS(Vertigo): 10→2Facial palsy: Unimproved |
Kim (2005) | 1 | RHS | Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯加味)Soyo-san(逍遙散加味)Boheol-tang(補血湯加味) | + | AC, EA, Cupping(wet), IR, Simple dressing | HBG, Narrative description of Skin Lesion, Blood Analysis(LFT) | Skin lesion: Eruption clearedHBG: V→I/II, LFT: W.N.L |
Eom (2006) | 1 | RHS | Ssanghwa-tang + Hyungbangpaedok-san (雙和湯合荊防敗毒散)Yongdamsagan-tang(龍膽瀉肝湯)Ssanghwa-tang(雙和湯) | - | AC | HBG, VAS for Pain, Laryngoscope | HBG: IV→III, VAS 2→0 Laryngoscope:Improved |
Cha (2008) | 1 | RHS | Ligigeopoong-san(理氣祛風散)Woogakseungma-tang(牛角升麻湯) | + | AC, EA, IR, FES, SSP, EST | Narrative description of Skin Lesions & Symptom, 5-grade palsy grading system, VAS for Pain | Skin lesion: Eruption improvedG2~4→G0(Totally Improved)VAS: 9→0 |
Choi (2012) | 1 | RHS | none | + | AC, EA | YGS, VAS | YGS: 4→39, VAS: 10→1 |
Jung (2015) | 1 | RHS | none | + | AC, EA, IR, Carbon, EST, UST, HP, Massage, Facial muscle exercise | HBG | HBG : VI→II |
Jo (2016) | 1 | RHS | Ligigeopoong-san(理氣祛風散加減)Bojoongikgi-tang(補中益氣湯加減) | + | AC, EA+magnetic stimulation | Photography, YGS, HBG, SFGS | YGS:24→30, HBG:IV→IISFGS: 34→83 |
Jo (2016) | 4 | RHS | Ligigeopoong-san(理氣祛風散)Bogigeopoong-san(補氣祛風散) | + | AC, Thread embedding therapy | HBG, YGS | 1) HBG: VI→V, YGS:3→72) HBG: IV→I, YGS:12→333) HBG: VI→V, YGS:3→94) HBG: III→I, YGS:23→37 |
Shin (2019) | 1 | RHS | Gamidaebo-tang(加味大補湯) | NR | AC, EA, PA(Sinbaro3) | DITI, NRS(Pain), HBG, YGS | DITI: Improved, NRS: 6→2, HBG:V→II, YGS:6→22 |